On Fri, 14 Aug 1992 16:24:06 EDT Sanjay Kapur said: >Another sample of mail that almost got sent to the list Just by coincedence, I've received several mail bounces from a site in the UK with very similar mail headers. Since JHUVM's LISTSERV recognized the ones I got as mail delivery errors, I thought it might be useful to point out the differences. In both cases, the Subject: lines have a lovely "%%" prepended to the useful information, which while *most* aesthetically pleasing, isn't trapped by LISTSERV. Also, we both have From: lines with "Mail_System" instead of "postmaster" or one of the other recognized userids. The difference is, luckily in my case, the encapsulated mail that was being returned, didn't have the addresses flipped ass-backwards in JANET order. So, my LISTSERV saw the mailing list address in the body of the mail message. In your case, your LISTSERV saw, Sender: [log in to unmask], which is total crap as far as everyone but JANET is concerned. Why were the mail headers in your rejections left in JANET order, while mine were in Internet order? I have no idea, and I'd suggest sending a note to the postmaster of the system that rejected the mail and the postmaster of the JANET mail gateway system. I've had good luck in getting help from the folks at the Bitnet/JANET gateway in the past, even when in a few cases, it proved rather difficult to isolate/resolve the problems. I personally don't think mail should be allowed back into Bitnet/Internet with unusable headers. And if some sites are going to make cute headers with "%%" gizmos to 'highlight' Subject: text and use unusual From: address in mail rejection notices, the text of the returned mail becomes a rather important piece of information. I'd argue that having the mail addresses in the encapsulated message in the proper order for the receiving network becomes necessary. And as I said, at least some JANET sites are formatting such headers in Internet order. My question to the postmaster(s) would be why don't they all work properly? > > Sanjay Kapur |Internet: [log in to unmask] > Systems Staff, Computing Services, |Bitnet: SKAPUR@USB > State University of New York, |SPAN/HEPnet: 44132::SKAPUR > Stony Brook, NY 11794-2400 |Phone:(516)632-8029, FAX:(516)632-8046 -jj