qOn Wed, 3 Mar 2004, Michael Johnson wrote:

> On Wed, 3 Mar 2004, Michael Johnson wrote:
> > Send= Private,Editor appears to result in filtering out non-subscriber
> > posts and trapping REVIEW subscribers' posts for moderation.  Does that
> > behavior you describe apply only to 1.8e?  My default option for new
> > subscribers is REVIEW, not NOPOST.
>
>
> On Wed, 3 Mar 2004, Dennis Budd wrote:
> > That is the same behavior that you obtain by using "Send= Private",
> > without the "Editor".  Looks to me like it's using "Private", ignoring
> > "Editor", and not flagging this as an error, which it really should be
> > doing.
>
> If the list is ignoring "Editor", then why am I still being asked to
> moderate posts from subscribers set to REVIEW, and why are subscribers not
> set to REVIEW being asked to approve their own messages?
>
> The documentation did not explicitly forbid "Private,Editor", but neither
> did it explicitly define the expected behavior of such a combination.
>
> In my less than 48 hours of experience with "Private,Editor", that
> combination does not behave identically to how you describe "Private" or
> "Editor" alone.  What I'm seeing is a desirable (IMHO) blend of both.
>
> --
> Michael
>