On Wed, 18 Nov 1992 13:35:44 CST Landy Manderson <USTS034@UABDPO> said:
 
>On Wed, 18 Nov 1992 13:47:15 EDT Helen P. Nulty said:
>>The problem is specific to MUSIC (it works fine from CMS).  From MUSIC,
>>if I add F=MAIL to the GET request the file is delivered properly.
>>Before 17e we did not have to do this.  We made modifications
>>to our RSCS to support our MUSIC node, SLUMUS, all of which worked
>>before 17e.  Below is a sample of the UNDELIVERABLE MAIL.
>
>Is it possible that your modifications (or MUSIC) are expecting the
>NETDATA tags to be in a particular order?  Eric is now generating the
>same tagdata as a CMS SENDFILE, but it is not in the same order.  If
>something on your end is expecting the 4th and 5th tagdata to always be
>destination node and userid (instead of checking the tagdata keys), then
>it would be confused by the new LISTSERV output.
 
Indeed. In the hope that it helps  diagnosing the problem, here is a dump
of the headers  generated by DMSDDL and LISTSERV (with  17E-001o) for the
same input file:
 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
                             DMSDDL headers
INMR01:
 0042 (LRECL)
    2 0050 (hex)
 1011 (FNODE)
    5 SEARN
 1012 (FUID)
    1 L
 1001 (TNODE)
    5 SEARN
 1002 (TUID)
    4 ERIC
 1024 (FTIME)
   20 19921117202253000000
 102F (NUMF)
    4 00000001 (hex)
INMR02:
 102C (SIZE)
    8 0000000000001000 (hex)
 003C (DSORG)
    2 4000 (hex)
 0042 (LRECL)
    4 00000025 (hex)
 1028 (UTILN)
    7 INMCOPY
 0049 (RECFM)
    2 0002 (hex)
 0002 (DSNAM)
    1 A
    7 PROFILE
    4 EXEC
 102D (FFM)
    1 1
 1021 (LCHG)
   20 19920927003421000000
INMR03:
 102C (SIZE)
    8 0000000000001000 (hex)
 003C (DSORG)
    2 4000 (hex)
 0042 (LRECL)
    4 00000050 (hex)
 0049 (RECFM)
    2 0001 (hex)
INMR06:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
                            LISTSERV headers
INMR01:
 1011 (FNODE)
    5 SEARN
 1012 (FUID)
    1 L
 1001 (TNODE)
    5 SEARN
 1002 (TUID)
    1 L
 1024 (FTIME)
   14 19921117205159
 102F (NUMF)
    1 01 (hex)
 0042 (LRECL)
    1 50 (hex)
INMR02:
 1028 (UTILN)
    7 INMCOPY
 0002 (DSNAM)
    1 A
    7 PROFILE
    4 EXEC
 102D (FFM)
    1 1
 1021 (LCHG)
   14 19920927003421
 0042 (LRECL)
    4 00000025 (hex)
 003C (DSORG)
    2 4000 (hex)
 0049 (RECFM)
    2 0002 (hex)
 102C (SIZE)
    4 00000000 (hex)
INMR03:
 003C (DSORG)
    2 4000 (hex)
 0049 (RECFM)
    2 0002 (hex)
 102C (SIZE)
    4 00000000 (hex)
 0042 (LRECL)
    1 50 (hex)
INMR06: