LSTSRV-L Archives

LISTSERV Site Administrators' Forum

LSTSRV-L

Options: Use Monospaced Font
Show Text Part by Default
Show All Mail Headers

Topic: [<< First] [< Prev] [Next >] [Last >>]

Print Reply
Jim Jones <[log in to unmask]>
Wed, 5 Sep 90 12:06:46 EDT
text/plain (36 lines)
 From time to time I receive mail failure messages (as postmaster for
 JHUVM) that I think should be sent elsewhere.  The specific case I'm
 thinking of involves users who use distribute jobs to send files over
 the network.  Consider the following scenario:
 
 - User X at node AAA sends a dist job to a backbone Listserv
 
 - Listserv at JHUVM handles part of the distribution since user Y
   at node JHUVMS is to receive a copy of the file.  (And JHUVM is
   the backbone Listserv closest to JHUVMS.)
 
 - PMDF on JHUVMS realizes that it cannot deliver mail to user Y and
   attempts to return the mail.  It picks up the address in the "Sender:"
   field and voila, Listserv@JHUVM ends up with the mail.
 
 So, being the postmaster, I receive mail from X@AAA destined for [log in to unmask]
 Since I didn't send it, it's not a mailing list maintained at JHUVM, and
 the destination address isn't my machine, I can't do anything about it.
 I end up forwarding the error info back to X@AAA and/or [log in to unmask]
 
 After talking to the person responsible for PMDF here, I'm not certain that
 he can configure his code in a way that will handle the situation any
 better.  My question to the list is, has anyone come up with a way to
 handle this type of situation?  Short of coding something like "return
 failed mail to 'Sender:' except when it's Listserv, then use 'From:'",
 what can be done?  Would anything break if Listserv included an "Errors-to:"
 header line when constructing the distributed mail?  If not, then perhaps
 the email address of the user submitting the job could be placed there.
 Then things like PMDF could key off the "Errors-to:" address rather than
 the "Sender:" field.
 
 Of course, I might be missing something obvious here.  If so, just
 clue me in, and I'll go away quietly... :-)
 
 -jj

ATOM RSS1 RSS2